lolder makes a good point. In addition, I'd like to ask how long you've driven you 2010? Based on your comment about keeping in EV mode makes me wonder about your driving technique(s). Trying to accelerate from a dead stop in EV mode is not very useful or practical as you stated. The simplest hypermiling method for surface streets is; accelerate normally to something under 47MPH, then release the pedal until your EV meter shows availability, then press the pedal and "sneak-up" using the red line to the top of the EV green box. Assuming you have 50%+ SoC, and, on reasonable flat road, you should be able to stay in EV for a mile or more unitl the SoC drops. If you're not using the display below, switch to it. If you're never dropping below 5/8 SoC, then you're not using the HVB efficiently, or your HVB reset didn't reset. You should achieve MPG segments on surface streets well over 40 MPG. On my 13 mi daily commute on surface streets, I see 45+MPG easily.
Good luck,
Jack in Ohio