I just bought some new Michelin Energy Saver tires to replace the stock tires when I made some friends with a few screws. Anyway I LOVE the tires. They're quiet, they appear to handle nicely (I don't drive the Milan very aggressively though), and they are very well reviewed. The only downside I see is that they are definitely only 3 season tires, there is very little siping and I suspect they will handle like a greased pig. Also on a 200 mile round trip highway cruise, with a few hours break in the middle for work, I gained between 2 and 3 miles per gallon.
Here is where is gets fun. I was checking tire pressures and detailing the car today when I realized the mechanic didn't inflate my tires correctly. The fronts were "correct" at 33 PSI but the rears were both at 30. So I gained 2-3 MPG with under inflated tires compared to stock tires inflated to 37 psi. I decided to bump them up and noticed that the sidewall max pressure is 51! I haven't seen tires that high in a long time. I put them at 42 to see how they ride and handle. I don't know if I'll get much more mpg out of them but the quick in town trip I took I seemed to feel the road better and were a tad more responsive to input from the wheel.
As a side note I would refrain from buying tires from Sears in the future. It took over a week to get the tires in, they were completely unable to find, track, or even know if I had ordered them until they arrived in the store. They tried to give me someone else's tires the first time I called and didn't catch the mistake until they were getting ready to print the work authorization. Then once they were in the store it took almost 30 minutes just to get through all the hoops and then another 90 minutes to have them mounted. On the up side I got new valve stems for free and the mechanic managed to put the tires on the car and balance them without hurting either the car or tires but he failed at putting a correct pressure in them. They ended up being competitively priced but that's about the best I can say of the whole process.